Loving God, Loving Others and Leading Others to do the Same

Home » Greg Lancaster Ministries » Why Jesus Had to Die if He Is God

Why Jesus Had to Die if He Is God

by

The Story of the King Who Took His Own Daughter’s 40 Lashes

“If He’s God, why couldn’t He just forgive?”

That is the question Shawn Ryan asked Pastor Josh Howerton on the Shawn Ryan Show. It is an honest question. Many people have asked it, some out loud and some only in their hearts. Maybe you have asked it too.

Pastor Josh did not hesitate. “Man, that’s like my favorite question to answer ever,” he said. Then he told a story he called the best illustration of why Jesus had to die on the cross he had ever heard. It is one of the clearest pictures of the Gospel you will ever hear. Watch it, and then let’s walk through it together.

Shawn Ryan asks Pastor Josh Howerton why Jesus had to die. Clip from Josh Howerton, The War for Christianity, Shawn Ryan Show #327, shared by Ex Nihilo.

Five Things We Will Learn

  1. Why God could not simply look the other way and still be just.
  2. The story of the king, the treasury, and the 40 lashes, as Pastor Josh Howerton told it.
  3. How the king was both just and the justifier of the ungodly.
  4. Why the cross shows that God is just and God is love at the same time.
  5. What it means that Jesus took your place, and how to receive what He has done.

The Question Behind the Question

Shawn’s question goes straight to the heart of it. If God is God, can’t He do whatever He wants? Couldn’t He just say, “You’re forgiven,” and be done with it?

Pastor Josh answered from Scripture first. “The Bible says that God did it that way so that He could be both,” he said. “Let me say it and then explain it. So He could be both just and the justifier of the ungodly.”

That comes from the book of Romans. Paul wrote that God presented Jesus as a sacrifice of atonement, and “He did it to demonstrate His justice at the present time, so as to be just and the one who justifies those who have faith in Jesus” (Romans 3:26). Paul also calls Him the God “who justifies the wicked” (Romans 4:5).

Think about it. A judge who lets the guilty walk away is not a good judge. A father who never forgives is not a loving father. God is perfectly both, and the cross is where both meet. Paul preached this same message of forgiveness and justification through Jesus in Acts 13.

The King, the Treasury, and the 40 Lashes

Here is the story as Pastor Josh told it.

Once upon a time, in a far-off kingdom, there was a king who was known by everyone in the kingdom to be the most just and loving king who had ever lived. Then it was discovered that somebody was stealing from the king’s treasury.

The king sent out an edict. Whoever was stealing from the treasury would receive 10 lashes. The theft continued, so he issued another decree: 20 lashes. The theft continued: 30 lashes. Finally the king issued a final decree. “When it’s discovered who’s stealing from the king’s treasury, it will be a sentence of 40 lashes.”

“Now, the problem with that,” Pastor Josh said, “was that 40 lashes was a death sentence.”

Still the theft continued, until at last the thief was found. It was none other than the king’s own daughter.

What Would the King Do?

A question began to ripple through the kingdom. What would the king do?

“Some thought he would forgive her, but then how would he be just? Some thought that he would issue the sentence, but then how would he be loving?”

Did you catch that? It is the same question Shawn asked. It is the question of every human heart standing before a holy God. If He simply forgives, where is His justice? If He simply punishes, where is His love?

“Now, Hit Her”

One day the entire kingdom was gathered. In front of everybody, the king’s own daughter was marched up to the podium. The executioner stood there and began to raise his whip to land the first lash.

As soon as he did, the king yelled, “Stop!”

Silence fell. The king strode forward and wrapped his body around his own daughter. He looked back over his shoulder and said, “Now, hit her.”

The executioner objected. “But king, those lashes will fall on you.”

The king answered, “The sentence must stand. It’s just. Hit her.”

And so 40 lashes fell on the body of the king that protected the body of his daughter. As Pastor Josh put it, “the king died in the stead of his daughter.”

Both Just and the Justifier

Then Pastor Josh brought it home. “The king was both just, because payment for the sin had to be made, and the king was the justifier of the ungodly. She went free because he took the penalty.”

You see, the sentence was not cancelled. It was carried. The law was not ignored. It was satisfied. And the one who carried it was the king himself.

That is the answer to “if He is God.” The cross is not God punishing someone else to spare Himself. In Christ, God came Himself. “God was reconciling the world to Himself in Christ, not counting men’s sins against them” (2 Corinthians 5:19). The King wrapped Himself around us and took the blows.

Isaiah saw it long before it happened: “But He was pierced for our transgressions, He was crushed for our iniquities; the punishment that brought us peace was upon Him, and by His wounds we are healed” (Isaiah 53:5). God’s kindness and His justice are never at war with each other. Read more in Pierced! The Kindness, Sternness, Justice, Mercy and Love of our Awesome God.

God Is Just, but God Is Love

“See, the reason Jesus had to die on a cross is because God is just, but God is love,” Pastor Josh said. “So He made the payment Himself.”

Then he pointed to the verse that says it plainly. In the 1984 NIV it reads, “For the wages of sin is death, but the gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord” (Romans 6:23).

Wages are earned. A gift is received. We earned the lashes. Jesus took them, and He holds out the gift.

“But God demonstrates His own love for us in this: While we were still sinners, Christ died for us” (Romans 5:8). The king did not wait for his daughter to clean herself up. He stepped in while she was still guilty. That is grace. It is the same grace and mercy we live from every day, in view of His mercy.

In My Place, Condemned He Stood

Pastor Josh closed with these words: “So it’s a substitutionary sacrifice. In my place, condemned He stood.”

Substitution means Someone takes your place. “God made Him who had no sin to be sin for us, so that in Him we might become the righteousness of God” (2 Corinthians 5:21). John the Baptist pointed to Jesus and said, “Look, the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world!” (John 1:29). He is the Lamb who was slain and is worthy.

Hear it with a shepherd’s heart. The daughter in this story is you and me. We have all taken from the King’s treasury. We have all broken His law. And the King did not stand far off. He came close. He wrapped Himself around us and took what we deserved.

What Will You Do With the King?

The daughter did nothing to earn her freedom. She went free because the king took her place. Your part is to receive what Jesus has done. Turn from your sin, put your trust in Him, and follow Him as Lord.

If you have never done that, you can do it right now. And if you already know Him, let this story stir your first love again. Then share it with someone who is asking the same question Shawn asked. This is what the cross and the empty tomb really mean for you and for all mankind.

A Prayer

Father, thank You that You are just and You are love. Thank You, Jesus, that You did not cancel the sentence but carried it. You were pierced for my transgressions and crushed for my iniquities. In my place, condemned You stood. I turn from my sin and I trust You as my Savior and Lord. Fill me with Your Holy Spirit, and help me tell others what You have done. In Jesus’ name. Amen.

Loving God, loving others, and leading others to do the same.

Related Reading

Begin Your Journey Today

Begin Your Journey Today

Jesus didn’t just call us to believe in Him—He called us to follow Him.

Step into the life He designed for you through Emmaus Road’s The Commands of Jesus . This is more than learning—it’s an invitation to walk with Him, obey Him, and experience Him in a real and powerful way.

You don’t want to miss this exciting adventure Jesus has called you into.

Start now:
https://GregLancaster.org/EmmausRoad

You may also like

Send this to a friend